THE OLD VIDEOTAPE IN THE SAFE

My mom had been hospitalized for over a week now. Nothing life-threatening, but enough for Dad to send me go through her things at home, just following a checklist. It felt routine, nothing unusual, until I opened the safe to put back her earings in the jewelry box. That’s when I saw it—a note sitting on top. It read, “The truth about Lucy”

The thing is… I’m Lucy.

Underneath the note was an old VHS tape. My heart raced as I grabbed it, making sure no one was around. Why would my name be on the note? What was so secret that my mother wanted to keep it from me?

I should have left it. I should have respected her privacy. But I didn’t.

I found the old VCR tucked away in the living room, dusted it off, and popped the tape in. Static flickered across the screen before the image became clear. There they were—my parents, young and vibrant, smiling at the camera.

I smiled too, nostalgic for a time I barely remembered. But my smile didn’t last long.

Because the next thing I saw… was me.

Or at least, a baby that looked exactly like me.

Mom was holding the baby—holding me. Dad was beside her, beaming with pride. She kissed the baby’s forehead and whispered, “She’s perfect.”

I expected warmth to flood my chest. Instead, a deep unease settled over me. Something about the way she said it felt… wrong. Forced.

Then, the screen flickered, and suddenly, the scene changed.

Now, my mother was alone. Her face was different—tense. She wasn’t smiling anymore. She was sitting in front of the camera, speaking directly to it.

“If you’re watching this, Lucy, it means I never got the chance to tell you the truth.”

I gripped the arms of the chair, my pulse pounding in my ears.

“I need you to know that we love you. We always have. But I have to tell you what we did… and why.”

My mother took a shaky breath before continuing.

“You’re not ours, Lucy. Not biologically.”

My stomach twisted.

“You were born to another woman.”

I felt the room tilt. My fingers curled into the fabric of my jeans.

No. That can’t be right. That doesn’t make sense.

She swallowed hard, looking like she was battling tears.

“We didn’t adopt you the legal way. We took you.”

I froze.

“Your real mother… She never abandoned you. She never gave you up. We stole you from the hospital the day you were born.”

The breath left my body. My mind screamed no, no, no! but the video kept playing, shattering everything I believed about my life.

Mom wiped her eyes and inhaled deeply.

“We thought we were doing the right thing. We had lost our own baby that same night. A stillbirth. I was out of my mind with grief, and when I saw you, saw the chance to have the daughter I’d dreamed of… I took it.”

I felt sick. My hands trembled.

“Your real parents, Lucy… they looked for you. They never stopped. But we covered our tracks. We moved states. Changed our names. Did everything to keep you.”

Tears blurred my vision.

“You deserve to know the truth. You deserve the chance to find them. I don’t know if you’ll ever forgive us, but you needed to hear it from me.”

Then, just before the screen cut to black, she whispered:

“I’m sorry.”

I sat there, frozen. My brain couldn’t process it.

Everything I knew—my family, my childhood, my identity—had just been ripped away in the span of a few minutes.

And then a terrifying thought hit me.

Did Dad know?

I scrambled to eject the tape, my hands shaking. I had to confront him. I had to know the full truth. But just as I turned to leave the room, I heard the front door open.

Dad was home.

For the first time in my life, I was afraid of him.

I took a deep breath and hid the tape behind me. I needed a plan. I couldn’t just blurt it out. I had to be careful. If he had kept a lie this big for my entire life, what else was he capable of?

He walked in, setting down the groceries, and smiled at me. “Hey, kiddo. What took you so long?”

I forced a smile. “Just… cleaning up some of Mom’s things.”

He nodded. “That’s good.”

I hesitated. Then, in the calmest voice I could manage, I asked, “Dad, do you remember the day I was born?”

His face changed ever so slightly. A flicker of something unreadable.

He chuckled, but it sounded off. “Of course. Best day of our lives.”

My stomach knotted.

I had my answer.

For days, I wrestled with what to do. If I went to the police, I would destroy my family. If I didn’t, I would be living a lie.

In the end, I chose to chase the truth.

I found an old news article from my birth year—a baby girl stolen from a hospital. I found a name. My real mother’s name.

And I found her.

She cried when I told her who I was. She held me like she had never let go.

As for my parents—the only ones I had ever known—I turned my back on them.

It broke me. It broke them too.

But in the end, the truth had to come out.

What would you do if you found out your whole life was built on a lie?